MMMM I think I am gonna step on some toes on this comment but I would have to say it is a draw, they both have there ups and downs, and both can be dull as hell at times, South Park has Eric Cartman to keep the show going, as Family Guy has Stewie to keep it going, I wonder who would win in a fight between the 2? MMMMM any thoughts on this matter... I personally think Eric would cut up peter and put him in his famous Chili cook off contest...LOL... I personally love both shows....