I think that David Lee was the best with VanHalen. He is an awesome showman and made a great additon to the band. Sammy Hagar did have some good songs but is more of a surfer dude type and not the edgey sex machine that David is. I wish that Eddie would come out with an all acoustic album that would rock. I think that if the band can play but the frontman sucks then it drags the band down and visa versa.